What’s In An Editor?

December 17, 2009 - 9:15 am 9 Comments

I’ve been fortunate.

My editors have been amazing women. As a former editor myself, I appreciate the work they do - reading and reading and reading and actually attending to, not only the author’s words, but the author’s intent. They have to pull out every error, every misplaced comma, every incorrect grammatical construct and either fix it or suggest an appropriate fix.

An editor has to make sure words flow seamlessly. Is an author guilty of relying upon too many commas? Too few? Does he or she overuse incomplete sentences? Does the author try to emphasize a character’s words by relying upon Bold print, caps or exclamation points? What about the adjectives and adverbs? Do they need to be culled? How much back story does the reader need - can it be trimmed or is it essential for understanding why our characters do what they do? Feel what they feel? Think what they think - erroneously or not?

A good editor doesn’t dumb things down. She doesn’t say - this word is too big for the readers. As a reader, I want to be challenged. How do you think I increased my vocabulary growing up? By reading. I read new words and I either understood them thanks to the context in which they appeared or I looked them up. One of my mentors taught - say what you have to say as simply as possible. So no, I don’t use…what are they called…ten dollar words when a ten cent word will suffice, but occasionally a scene requires a word that says a bit more than - he walked across the room. Perhaps he strode or stomped or danced or skipped or hurried or tripped or picked his way across the cluttered room.

I will take this sentence - she stood on the curb, in rapt attention, watching the parade pass by, over this sentence - she was on the curb while the parade went by - any day.

Tweet This Post

Related posts:

  1. The Power of Language. Do you have any favorites? I do. I love it...
  2. Unerotic words to avoid by… Not in my books…and no offense intended to any author...
  3. The ‘effin’ ‘ef’ word. I’m the first to admit that I have a potty...
  4. Sarah, over at Smart Bitches, Trashy Books was kind enough to answer some questions for me. I...
  5. Worth Repeating, Lesli Richardson… Check out Lesli Richardson, over at her blog: http://www.leslirichardson.com/ Here’s...

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

9 Responses to “What’s In An Editor?”

  1. Fran Lee Says:

    I was gonna say, “sugar and spice and everything nice”, then you go all serious on me. Since my wonderful editor is retiring from editing romance books to work a job that allows her to eat, have a roof over her head, and save for her future (silly wench!) I have to say that I agree wholeheartedly with your observations, and pray that I get another one as great.

  2. Julia Barrett Says:

    Since I have three edits all due at once, I have editors on my brain. Hope you love your new editor.

  3. Tessie Bradford Says:

    I have been through the editing process three times with three different editors! I’ve learned a great deal from each experience.

  4. Nicole H. Says:

    You know I appreciate this blog immensely! I edit, both freelance and for a publisher, and to be appreciated or acknowledged for helping is a treat. Wonderful post! I hope your previous editors see this and get a warm fuzzy feeling!

  5. Julia Barrett Says:

    Thanks, Nicole. Me too!

  6. Mia Watts Says:

    *heh heh heh*

    :)

  7. Julia Barrett Says:

    Oh, Mia. Make me laugh, why don’t ya!

  8. anny cook Says:

    All editors have something to add to our experience.

  9. Julia Barrett Says:

    You are very right, Anny. I’ve been lucky with the support I’ve received from my editors.

Leave a Reply


Bad Behavior has blocked 145 access attempts in the last 7 days.

Cute Critters theme is designed by Thoughts.com and coded by Web Hosting Pal.